
Dinner Menu
Menu
Menu selections and prices are subject to change without notice.
Tuesday Pasta Night
Every Tuesday 3-10 PM. Our full homemade pasta menu at an unbelievable value.
Menu Highlights


Calamari

Antipasto

Scallops Scampi

Seafood Pasta Feature

Featured Cocktail
Appetizers
Steamed Clams
Fresh clams prepared to order.
$13.50
Raw Oyster Platter
Fresh oysters served chilled.
$22.95
Steamed Shrimp
Steamed shrimp appetizer.
$17.95
Grilled Andouille Sausage
Grilled sausage with house preparation.
$12.95
Escargot
Classic escargot preparation.
$12.95
Mussels Marinara
Mussels in marinara sauce.
$12.50
Shrimp Cocktail
Classic chilled shrimp cocktail.
$12.95
Assorted Platter
Mixed appetizer platter.
$11.95
Stuffed Mushrooms
House stuffed mushrooms.
$12.95
Prosciutto Wrapped Shrimp (4)
Four shrimp wrapped in prosciutto.
$12.95
Grilled Calamari
House SpecialtyGuest favorite grilled calamari.
$13.95
Breaded Calamari
House SpecialtyGuest favorite breaded calamari.
$15.95
Fried Smelts
Crisp fried smelts.
$11.95
Potato Skins a la Butchie
Potato skins with house style toppings.
$10.95
Marinated Artichokes
Marinated artichoke appetizer.
$7.95
Fried Cheese
Fried cheese starter.
$10.95
Marinated Hot Peppers
Marinated hot peppers.
$8.95
Crostini
Toasted bread appetizer.
$10.95
Soups & Salads
Fresh Spinach Salad
Mushrooms, croutons, and dressing of your choice. Hot bacon dressing add $1.00.
$10.25
Antipasto
House SpecialtyMeats, vegetables, cheeses, peppers, and olives over lettuce.
Individual $9.50 | Small $11.00 | Large $13.00
Italian Tomato Salad
Fresh tomato salad.
$9.00
Tossed Salad
House tossed salad.
Small $6.50 | Large $8.00
Spring Mix or Leaf Lettuce Salad
Choice of spring mix or leaf lettuce.
Small $7.50 | Large $9.50
Homemade Wedding Soup
Homemade wedding soup.
Cup $5.50 | Bowl $6.50
Onion Soup
Traditional onion soup.
Cup $6.00 | Bowl $7.00
Homemade Pasta
Made in-house, every day.
Homemade Fettuccini Alfredo
Homemade noodles tossed in a thick ricotta cheese sauce.
$15.50
Homemade Fettuccini Maria
Homemade noodles with fresh vegetables and cheese in a light cream sauce.
$17.00
Linguini with White Clam Sauce
Linguini with white clam sauce.
$17.50
Homemade Lasagna
House SpecialtyHouse lasagna made from scratch.
$14.95
Homemade Cavatelli
House cavatelli made from scratch.
$14.95
Homemade Ravioli
House SpecialtyHouse ravioli made from scratch.
$14.95
Homemade Fettuccini
Homemade fettuccini with sauce of choice.
$14.75
Spaghetti with Meatball
Classic spaghetti with one meatball.
Large $12.75 | Small $11.75
Rigatoni with Meatball
Rigatoni with one meatball.
Large $12.75 | Small $11.75
Linguini with Meatball
Linguini with one meatball.
Large $12.75 | Small $11.75
Gluten-Free Pasta
Gluten-free spaghetti and wheat pasta available upon request for an upcharge.
[PLACEHOLDER: current upcharge not listed online]
Entrees
Chicken Captiva
Boneless chicken breast topped with creamy mustard sauce, cheese, fresh crab, shrimp, and bacon bits.
$23.95
Veal Parmigiana
Milk-fed veal with house breading, melted cheese, and famous sauce.
$23.95
Breaded Veal Cutlet
Tender milk-fed veal with seasoned breading, deep fried then baked.
$21.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
Thin-sliced eggplant with Italian seasoning, deep fried and topped with cheese and sauce.
$17.95
Italian Chopped Sirloin Parmigiana
Ground beef with onions, peppers, mushrooms, and pepperoni, broiled and topped with cheese and sauce.
$17.95
Chicken Cutlet
Boneless chicken breast with house seasoning, deep fried then baked.
$18.95
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken breast topped with cheese and sauce.
$19.95
Veal Piccata
Milk-fed veal sauteed with lemon butter, tomato, mushrooms, and garlic sauce.
$23.95
Veal Romano
Veal breaded, egg battered, and sauteed.
$23.95
Filet Mignon
Broiled to order.
King Cut Market Price | Queen Cut Market Price
New York Strip
Choice beef grilled to your specification with mushrooms and redskin potatoes.
Market Price
Delmonico Steak
Tender and meaty choice cut.
Market Price
Marinated Steak Tips
House SpecialtyIn Rizzo's famous marinade.
Market Price
Chicken Neapolitan
Boneless chicken breast marinated in house dressing and broiled.
$18.95
Pork Porterhouse
12-14 ounce center-cut porterhouse, grilled or Cajun style.
$19.95
Ham Steak
Thick grilled ham steak served with applesauce.
$16.95
Captiva Sauce Add-On
House-made crab, shrimp, bacon bits, cheese, and Dijon cream sauce.
$8.00
Crab Scampi
Seafood specialty from the sea section.
$23.95
Shrimp and Scallops Scampi
Shrimp and scallops in scampi style.
$25.50
Shrimp Scampi
Classic shrimp scampi.
$22.50
Langostino Scampi
Langostino scampi preparation.
$24.95
Shrimp Anthony
House shrimp specialty.
$22.95
Grilled Salmon
Grilled salmon prepared to order.
$24.50
Grilled Tuna
Grilled tuna prepared to order.
$24.50
Sea Scallops
Sea scallops entree.
$24.95
Crab Cakes
House crab cakes.
$20.95
Baked Stuffed Shrimp
Baked stuffed shrimp.
$22.50
Fresh Baked Stuffed Flounder
Baked stuffed flounder.
$22.95
Shrimp a la Butchie
Breaded shrimp, fried and topped with cheese and marinara sauce.
$19.50
Baked Haddock
House SpecialtyFresh baked haddock.
$18.50
Haddock Marinara
Haddock with marinara.
$18.95
Breaded Filet of Fish
Breaded filet of fish.
$18.50
Pizza
Plain Pizza
Small with extra toppings $1.25 each. Large with extra toppings $1.50 each.
Small $12.00 | Large $15.00
White Seafood Pizza
Seafood and cheese layered with butter and garlic sauce.
$14.95
Sandwiches
[PLACEHOLDER: Sandwich selections]
The current website menu does not publish sandwich names or prices.
[PLACEHOLDER: Call for current sandwich pricing]
Desserts
Dessert Selection
Homemade Apple Pie, Homemade Chocolate Cheesecake, Homemade Carrot Cake, Tiramisu, New York Cheesecake, Cannoli, Dolce Spud, Chocolate Mousse.
[PLACEHOLDER: Individual dessert prices are not listed online]
Cocktails & Bar
Espresso Martini
House SpecialtyGuest favorite cocktail from review mentions.
[PLACEHOLDER: Cocktail pricing is not published on the website]
Wine
Large Wine Selection
The restaurant offers an extensive in-house wine list.
[PLACEHOLDER: In-house wine list pricing]
Beer
Beer Selection
Beer options are available at the bar.
[PLACEHOLDER: In-house beer list pricing]
Kids Corner
Child-sized portions for guests 10 years old and under.
Breaded Chicken Strips
Served with french fries and a salad.
$8.95
Shrimp in a Basket
Served with french fries and a salad.
$8.95
Spaghetti or Rigatoni
Served with one meatball and a salad.
$8.95
Menu subject to change. Call for daily specials and seasonal items.